Best Album 1994 Round 3: Creepin' On Ah Come Up vs. Illmatic (A)

vs.

Illmatic is the better of these two EPs.

Illmatic easily

And it's NOT an EP, damnit!

Nas...

LOL @ Myestro

Never heard the Bone but Nas gets the vote anyway

Illmatic wins but not easily.

Highsmith wrote:

Never heard the Bone but Nas gets the vote anyway

If you're gonna vote against Bone without hearing, you should just vote on the other threads with albums you ain't heard. There's no sense in picking and choosing when to employ the "no vote"

Bone easily.

Creepin debuted 5 classic emcees to the world, illmatic only one, I think the answer is clear.

Southern Rap Pro wrote:

Creepin debuted 5 classic emcees to the world, illmatic only one, I think the answer is clear.

You're fucking biased!!!

I feel you Terry but everyone else picks and chooses what/why they vote and don't vote so I don't see any difference....

Highsmith wrote:

I feel you Terry but everyone else picks and chooses what/why they vote and don't vote so I don't see any difference....

Except for me, I don't vote if I haven't heard an album, don't think I've ever broken from that.

Southern Rap Pro wrote:

Creepin debuted 5 classic emcees to the world, illmatic only one, I think the answer is clear.

Yep the answer is clearly Nas because he's better than all of Bone combined!

I just realized I didn't vote, going with Bone, why not.

Half wrote:

I just realized I didn't vote, going with Bone, why not.

It's all good, Illmatic's gonna win anyway.

KJ Styles wrote:

Half wrote:

I just realized I didn't vote, going with Bone, why not.

It's all good, Illmatic's gonna win anyway.

Yeah I know, hence the "why not"

EASILY!

but Half you do make votes to keep things interesting.....lol So that's basically the same thing.

Highsmith wrote:

but Half you do make votes to keep things interesting.....lol So that's basically the same thing.

Haha that's true, although I've heard both albums when I do that. I have no problem with how you vote by the way, just giving my two cents on the "default" voting idea.

Vote default. Who cares? Technically, if you haven't heard an album, you can't like it better than one you have heard (unless that one is extremely terrible)

Illmatic wins pretty friggin' easily for me