NFL Question

Subject: NFL Question Tue 29 Nov 2011, 3:57 am

Mainly to KJ and Powell, but to everyone in general, if the Packers end up going undefeated and win the Super Bowl, where does Aaron Rodgers land on your all time QB list?

Subject: Re: NFL Question Tue 29 Nov 2011, 10:16 am

Man, that's tough. 4 years isn't a lot of time, but we would be talking about a 2 time Superbowl winner and a QB who led his team to a perfect season. There is also no way Rodgers does not win the league MVP if your scenario actually happens so that would be another feather in his cap. I think Brady, Elway and Montana would still be untouchable, but comparing him to and/or ranking him higher than guys like Brees, both Mannings, Warner, Roethlisberger, Aikman, Bradshaw, Young, and Simms is certainly a possibility. Even comparing him to Favre and Marino would be a good debate.

Subject: Re: NFL Question Tue 29 Nov 2011, 11:18 am

Rodgers is going to be so much better than Mr System, i mean Brady, when its all said and done.

and Aikman shouldnt even be in the same sentence as those other guys, no offense to him or Dallas fans, but he doesnt compare

and Marino is GOAT, fuck a ring

Subject: Re: NFL Question Tue 29 Nov 2011, 12:03 pm

Laced With Slang wrote:: Rodgers is going to be so much better than Mr System, i mean Brady, when its all said and done.

and Aikman shouldnt even be in the same sentence as those other guys, no offense to him or Dallas fans, but he doesnt compare

and Marino is GOAT, fuck a ring

I sure hope so, but until he gets 3 rings and 2 MVP awards Brady will be considered better. I agree that Brady is Mr. System though, and one of his MVP's should be residing in Randy Moss' house.

Subject: Re: NFL Question Tue 29 Nov 2011, 12:08 pm

both mannings... lmao....

Subject: Re: NFL Question Tue 29 Nov 2011, 12:28 pm

SyRuP Sippa wrote:: both mannings... lmao....

Eli and Peyton>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Tony Homo EASILY! Laughing My Ass Off

as for your question Shaun...Rodgers if he completes everything that you said would be a top 5 QB of all-time IMO and move Dan Marino out of my top 5 due to a lack of a ring....(Marino would slide down to number 6)....to top Montana, Brady, or Elway he's just going to need to do it a little longer and maybe win at least one more ring after this one IN MY OPINION....doing what you said here would place him above Favre ever so slightly because that would mean he would have brought multiple rings to Green Bay.....

Subject: Re: NFL Question Tue 29 Nov 2011, 1:18 pm

yeah... but eli isn't a winner mayne! He's lost the last three games mayne! I think the Giants would love to have them some Tebow because he's a winner maybe! Tebow>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Peyton because Peyton hasn't been winning. Tebow >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Eli because Eli hasn't inspired brandon jacobs like Tebow inspired Willis.

Subject: Re: NFL Question Tue 29 Nov 2011, 1:20 pm

SyRuP Sippa wrote:: yeah... but eli isn't a winner mayne! He's lost the last three games mayne! I think the Giants would love to have them some Tebow because he's a winner maybe! Tebow>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Peyton because Peyton hasn't been winning. Tebow >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Eli because Eli hasn't inspired brandon jacobs like Tebow inspired Willis.

Subject: Re: NFL Question Tue 29 Nov 2011, 4:18 pm

a new spin on an all time classic....your the first person I thought of when I saw it Pedro.....lol

Go Hawks Posts : 4016 Join date : 2009-09-24

T. Myers wrote:: Man, that's tough. 4 years isn't a lot of time, but we would be talking about a 2 time Superbowl winner and a QB who led his team to a perfect season. There is also no way Rodgers does not win the league MVP if your scenario actually happens so that would be another feather in his cap. I think Brady, Elway and Montana would still be untouchable, but comparing him to and/or ranking him higher than guys like Brees, both Mannings, Warner, Roethlisberger, Aikman, Bradshaw, Young, and Simms is certainly a possibility. Even comparing him to Favre and Marino would be a good debate.

lol Eli shouldn't even be mentioned....lol....lol...lol. And before Mama Bubba comes in and says something about Matt Ryan...Matt Ryan won't be mentioned in that group as well, I agree...yadaya.

Subject: Re: NFL Question Tue 29 Nov 2011, 6:23 pm

Fuck all the bullshit side chatter, I'm gonna stick to the topic at hand

If Aaron Rodgers does go 19-0 this season, I'd say he's a Top 20 QB of all time.

Some may say that's too low but like Terry said, 4 SEASON is not enough time. I mean look at Terrell Davis, dude only played 4 seasons and he won 2 Super Bowls and an MVP award yet isn't in the Hall Of Fame. It can be argued that he's the reason why John Elway EVER won a ring.

Rodgers will be a Hall Of Famer easily if he completes the cycle simply because he's a QB. But for him to get to Top 5-10 of all time status he's gotta play at least 2-3 more years on the same level he's been playing at IMO.

Subject: Re: NFL Question Wed 30 Nov 2011, 1:00 am

Common Scholars wrote:

T. Myers wrote:: Man, that's tough. 4 years isn't a lot of time, but we would be talking about a 2 time Superbowl winner and a QB who led his team to a perfect season. There is also no way Rodgers does not win the league MVP if your scenario actually happens so that would be another feather in his cap. I think Brady, Elway and Montana would still be untouchable, but comparing him to and/or ranking him higher than guys like Brees, both Mannings, Warner, Roethlisberger, Aikman, Bradshaw, Young, and Simms is certainly a possibility. Even comparing him to Favre and Marino would be a good debate.

lol Eli shouldn't even be mentioned....lol....lol...lol. And before Mama Bubba comes in and says something about Matt Ryan...Matt Ryan won't be mentioned in that group as well, I agree...yadaya.

Eli Manning>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>matt ryan