Ghost vs. Jay (Discog vs. Discog)

Subject: Ghost vs. Jay (Discog vs. Discog) Mon 22 Mar 2010, 10:35 pm

Ghostface Killah vs. Jay-Z

Ironman vs. Reasonable Doubt

Big Doe Rehab vs. In My Lifetime

More Fish vs. Roc La Familia the Dynasty

Pretty Toney vs. Hard Knock Life

Supreme Clientele vs. Blueprint

Bulletproof Wallets vs. The Gift & the Curse

Ghostdini vs. American Gangster

Fishscale vs. The Black Album

Enjoy!

Hi, My Name Is! Posts : 574 Join date : 2009-09-28

Ghostface Killah vs. Jay-Z

Ironman vs. Reasonable Doubt

Big Doe Rehab vs. In My Lifetime

More Fish vs. Roc La Familia the Dynasty

Pretty Toney vs. Hard Knock Life

Supreme Clientele vs. Blueprint

Bulletproof Wallets vs. The Gift & the Curse

Ghostdini vs. American Gangster

Fishscale vs. The Black Album

Subject: Re: Ghost vs. Jay (Discog vs. Discog) Mon 22 Mar 2010, 10:40 pm

Ghostface Killah vs. Jay-Z - easily

Ironman vs. Reasonable Doubt

Big Doe Rehab vs. In My Lifetime

More Fish vs. Roc La Familia the Dynasty

Pretty Toney vs. Hard Knock Life

Supreme Clientele vs. Blueprint

Bulletproof Wallets vs. The Gift & the Curse

Ghostdini vs. American Gangster

Fishscale vs. The Black Album - i guess Fishscale but their probably tied, in the other thread i ranked Fishscale higher cuz i bump it more

Guest

I thought we did this shit before, but whatever.......

Ghostface Killah vs. Jay-Z

Ironman vs. Reasonable Doubt

Big Doe Rehab vs. In My Lifetime Vol 1

More Fish vs. Roc La Familia the Dynasty

Pretty Toney vs. Hard Knock Life

Supreme Clientele vs. Blueprint- I would have said Blueprint a year or so ago, but I've been spinning SC much more and I'm diggin that album more than BP nowadays

Bulletproof Wallets vs. The Gift & the Curse- Not a fan of either album but BW is the lesser of two evils. Gift & The Curse is one of the most disappointing albums of all time IMO.

Ghostdini vs. American Gangster

Fishscale vs. The Black Album

I like Ghostface a lot, but Jay wins based on these particular matchups.

Subject: Re: Ghost vs. Jay (Discog vs. Discog) Mon 22 Mar 2010, 11:18 pm

In short...the only Jay album I'd pick over Ghost in these particular match ups is In My Lifetime over Big Doe Rehab.

The rest is all Brother Starks, in my humble opinion.

Subject: Re: Ghost vs. Jay (Discog vs. Discog) Mon 22 Mar 2010, 11:22 pm

Ghostface Killah vs. Jay-Z- Ghostface

Ironman vs. Reasonable Doubt- Ironman

Big Doe Rehab vs. In My Lifetime- In My Lifetime

More Fish vs. Roc La Familia the Dynasty- More Fish

Pretty Toney vs. Hard Knock Life- Pretty Toney

Supreme Clientele vs. Blueprint- Supreme Clientele

Bulletproof Wallets vs. The Gift & the Curse- Bulletproof Wallets

Ghostdini vs. American Gangster- Haven't heard Ghostdini

Fishscale vs. The Black Album- Black Album

Subject: Re: Ghost vs. Jay (Discog vs. Discog) Tue 23 Mar 2010, 8:27 am

Ghostface Killah vs. Jay-Z-Jay-Z

Ironman vs. Reasonable Doubt-PUSH

Big Doe Rehab vs. In My Lifetime-In My Lifetime

More Fish vs. Roc La Familia the Dynasty-Roc La Familia

Pretty Toney vs. Hard Knock Life-Pretty Toney

Supreme Clientele vs. Blueprint-Supreme Clientele

Bulletproof Wallets vs. The Gift & the Curse-Bulletproof Wallets

Ghostdini vs. American Gangster-American Gangster

Fishscale vs. The Black Album-The Black Album

In my opinion Jay-Z is clearly the better artist overall than Ghost and he's better than him lyrically as well....Ghost is no joke but is not on Jay's level as an artist overall-IN MY OPINION!

Subject: Re: Ghost vs. Jay (Discog vs. Discog) Tue 23 Mar 2010, 8:32 am

Ghostface Killah vs. Jay-Z but it's really close. Both are top 25 mc's IMO

Ironman vs. Reasonable Doubt

Big Doe Rehab vs. In My Lifetime

More Fish vs. Roc La Familia the Dynasty

Pretty Toney vs. Hard Knock Life

Supreme Clientele vs. Blueprint

Bulletproof Wallets vs. The Gift & the Curse

Ghostdini vs. American Gangster

Fishscale vs. The Black Album-both are personal classics to me, but there is nothing on Fishscale as wack as Change Clothes IMO

Guest

Ghostface Killah vs. Jay-Z- Jay's top 10 Ghost's top 20 for me.

Ironman vs. Reasonable Doubt- a tad over RD.

Big Doe Rehab vs. In My Lifetime

More Fish vs. Roc La Familia the Dynasty

Pretty Toney vs. Hard Knock Life

Supreme Clientele vs. Blueprint

Bulletproof Wallets vs. The Gift & the Curse

Ghostdini vs. American Gangster

Fishscale vs. The Black Album

Subject: Re: Ghost vs. Jay (Discog vs. Discog) Tue 23 Mar 2010, 11:21 am

TheHazardous wrote:: Ghostface Killah vs. Jay-Z

Ironman vs. Reasonable Doubt

Big Doe Rehab vs. In My Lifetime

More Fish vs. Roc La Familia the Dynasty

Pretty Toney vs. Hard Knock Life

Supreme Clientele vs. Blueprint

Bulletproof Wallets vs. The Gift & the Curse

Ghostdini vs. American Gangster

Fishscale vs. The Black Album

Enjoy!

Go Hawks Posts : 4016 Join date : 2009-09-24

TheHazardous wrote:: Ghostface Killah vs. Jay-Z- Jay-Z, I enjoy his albums more.

Ironman vs. Reasonable Doubt- Reasonable Doubt easily

Big Doe Rehab vs. In My Lifetime- In My Lifetime easily

More Fish vs. Roc La Familia the Dynasty- Roc La Familia easily

Pretty Toney vs. Hard Knock Life- Pretty Toney

Supreme Clientele vs. Blueprint- DAMN I'll go with Blueprint in a real close matchup

Bulletproof Wallets vs. The Gift & the Curse- The Gift & the Curse

Ghostdini vs. American Gangster- American Gangster

Fishscale vs. The Black Album- Black Album

Enjoy!

Guest

Ghostface Killah vs. Jay-Z

Ironman vs. Reasonable Doubt

Big Doe Rehab vs. In My Lifetime

More Fish vs. Roc La Familia the Dynasty

Pretty Toney vs. Hard Knock Life

Supreme Clientele vs. Blueprint

Bulletproof Wallets vs. The Gift & the Curse

Ghostdini vs. American Gangster

Fishscale vs. The Black Album

Guest

Ghostface Killah vs. Jay-Z
Jay-Z

Ironman vs. Reasonable Doubt
Reasonable Doubt

Big Doe Rehab vs. In My Lifetime
A *slight* tough one for me, but I'm going with In My Lifetime Vol. 1

More Fish vs. Roc La Familia the Dynasty
The Dynasty Roc La Familia

Pretty Toney vs. Hard Knock Life
Hard Knock Life

Supreme Clientele vs. Blueprint
Blueprint

Bulletproof Wallets vs. The Gift & the Curse
I was starting to give this to Bulletproof Wallets, but thinking about Disc 2 and the best songs from Disc 1 gives the nod to Jay

Ghostdini vs. American Gangster
American Gangster

Fishscale vs. The Black Album
The Black Album

Well, as you can see, Jay wins in a landslide for me, respectively. Don't get me wrong, I'm a long time fan of the Wu and I own all of Ghost's albums, but, as usual, I had to keep it real with this one. Oh yeah, just so you all know, Jay is my #2 after Nas, and not to turn this into a Nas thread, but NO ONE is ever going to knock him out of that spot!