Top 10 Individual Artists by Region (Final)

Subject: Top 10 Individual Artists by Region (Final) Wed 02 Sep 2009, 3:23 pm

East:
1. KRS-One
2. Kool G Rap
3. Big Daddy Kane
4. Rakim
5. Chuck D
6. Nas
7. Ghostface Killah
8. Jay-Z
9. GZA
10. Pharoahe Monch

South:
1. Andre 3000
2. Scarface
3. Cee-Lo
4. Bun-B
5. K-Rino
6. Ludacris
7. Big Boi
8. MJG
9. Z-Ro
10. T.I.

Midwest:
1. Eminem
2. Common
3. Tech N9ne
4. One Be Lo
5. Brother Ali
6. Royce Da 5'9
7. Twista
8. Bizzy Bone
9. Vakill
10. Krayzie Bone

West:
1. Ice Cube
2. 2Pac
3. DJ Quik
4. Del Tha Funkee Homosapien
5. Spice 1
6. B-Real
7. Ice-T
8. Snoop Dogg
9. Kurupt
10. E-40

Nice to see Kanye & Lupe got knocked out...lol.

Guest

get on chat, al!

wrote:: get on chat, al!

I tried. It won't let me. It brings me to another window and puts me in a chat box of my own.....(?).

Guest

smh don't log onto the "dope chatbox". Regular chatbox.

wrote:: smh don't log onto the "dope chatbox". Regular chatbox.

Oh, ok...lol

Guest

Alan wrote:: Nice to see Kanye & Lupe got knocked out...lol.

:finger: .....biiitch!

Guest

Alan wrote:: Nice to see Kanye & Lupe got knocked out...lol.

What the fuck ever, I still say they're better than all but the Top 2.

KJ Styles wrote:: What the fuck ever, I still say they're better than all but the Top 2.

hahaha good one

I wanna take the east list and wipe my ass with it...lol

other than that everything looks just dandy!

E-4000, Ya Smell Me? Posts : 4876 Join date : 2009-05-31

The midwest lineup just shows that a lot of those involved aren't educated on Vakill.

And that Common's fans are living in the past.

Vakill hasn't accomplished nearly as much as Common in his career.

Guest

D.Powell wrote:: I wanna take the east list and wipe my ass with it...lol

other than that everything looks just dandy!

Add Biggie, subtract Monch, change the order, and the East list is fine.

While GZA and Ghostface probably don't belong objectively either, they have strong catalogs so I have no problem with them being there.

Guest

Jason wrote:: Vakill hasn't accomplished nearly as much as Common in his career.

Nope he hasn't. While I like Vakill, he's got a long way to go to be as accomplished as Common.

E-4000, Ya Smell Me? Posts : 4876 Join date : 2009-05-31

So Common's shitty albums don't count against him?

To be fair, he's about 50/50. He hasn't dropped anything over 3 stars in damn near 10 years. Four flops in a row adds up to washed up.

"Be" is damn near 5 stars...

Guest

Yeah, Be, Finding Forever are both dope... don't know where this hate comes from.

Universal Mind Control is the only Common album I'd give less than 3 stars. I have both EC and FF at 3.5, and Be at 4.5.

Vakill is only two albums into his career, and while both are good, neither is a Resurrection, and we don't know how the rest of his career is going to go, how he's gonna sound 8 albums in.

Last edited by D.Powell on Thu 03 Sep 2009, 8:07 am; edited 1 time in total

KJ Styles wrote:

D.Powell wrote:: I wanna take the east list and wipe my ass with it...lol

other than that everything looks just dandy!

Add Biggie, subtract Monch, change the order, and the East list is fine.

While GZA and Ghostface probably don't belong objectively either, they have strong catalogs so I have no problem with them being there.

I disagree man....you gotta take out Monch, GZA and Ghostface and add Biggie, Cool J, and Black Thought and then you have a definitive EAST coast list IMO....

an EAST coast list that includes those three couldn't be beat IMO

Jason wrote:: Universal Mind Control is the only Common album I'd give less than 3 stars. I have both EC and FF at 3.5, and Be at 4.5.

Vakill is only two albums into his career, and while both are good, neither is a Resurrection, and we don't know how the rest of his career is going to go, how he's gonna sound 8 albums in.

Wow I actually co-sign Jason here except that I've got Be at 3.75 to 4 stars and Finding Forever at 4.25 stars.....Common deserves to be right where he is at IMO...he's one of the best to ever do it outta the Midwest...IMO!

Shaun wrote:: "Be" is damn near 5 stars...

Now I know who you really are.........Common...........

Guest

D.Powell wrote:

KJ Styles wrote:

D.Powell wrote:: I wanna take the east list and wipe my ass with it...lol

other than that everything looks just dandy!

Add Biggie, subtract Monch, change the order, and the East list is fine.

While GZA and Ghostface probably don't belong objectively either, they have strong catalogs so I have no problem with them being there.

I disagree man....you gotta take out Monch, GZA and Ghostface and add Biggie, Cool J, and Black Thought and then you have a definitive EAST coast list IMO....

an EAST coast list that includes those three couldn't be beat IMO

We still aren't gonna see eye to eye on LL. But I co-sign Biggie and Black Thought.

Guest

D.Powell wrote:

Jason wrote:: Universal Mind Control is the only Common album I'd give less than 3 stars. I have both EC and FF at 3.5, and Be at 4.5.

Vakill is only two albums into his career, and while both are good, neither is a Resurrection, and we don't know how the rest of his career is going to go, how he's gonna sound 8 albums in.

Wow I actually co-sign Jason here except that I've got Be at 3.75 to 4 stars and Finding Forever at 4.25 stars.....Common deserves to be right where he is at IMO...he's one of the best to ever do it outta the Midwest...IMO!

You're CRAZY dude. Be is a BANGER. I've got that at 4.25 stars and FF at 4 stars. That said, I agree about him being one of the best from the Midwest, and a Top 20-30 MC of all time.

Calm down KJ....lol

Be to me is not Common's best work by far...it's almost looked at the same way that The Blueprint is looked at by Jay-Z and that's not his best work either IMO....I thought Finding Forever was a better effort...I thought Kanye used even stronger beats on that effort..

as for Cool J of course we aren't going to agree if you don't think he should be listed on the top 10 of all-time east coast list...if Biggie should be on it, then Cool J should be on it above him EASILY....and I agree that Biggie should be on it...in terms of my personal list Biggie is number 3 and Cool J is number 5, but if we are talking about the GOATS from the east of all-time then I think Cool J is ahead of him too....but they both deserve to be on the list...

Guest

D.Powell wrote:: Calm down KJ....lol

Be to me is not Common's best work by far...it's almost looked at the same way that The Blueprint is looked at by Jay-Z and that's not his best work either IMO....I thought Finding Forever was a better effort...I thought Kanye used even stronger beats on that effort..

I don't think Be is Common's BEST effort, that honor goes to Resurrection. But I do think it's one of his better efforts. I really like Go, Testify, The Food, The Corner, Faithful, and Real People. Not many skip tracks on it for me.

Finding Forever was a dope album too, better than most give it credit for, but I slightly prefer Be overall. After songs like The People, I Need You, The Game, and Southside, the quality dips a bit. I still dig it though, and I agree that Kanye's production was dope on both albums.

My Common ratings:
Resurrection (5 stars)
Like Water For Chocolate (5 stars)
One Day It'll All Make Sense (4.5 stars)
Be (4.25 stars)
Finding Forver (4 stars)
Can I Borrow A Dollar (4 stars)
Electric Circus (3.5 stars)
Universal Mind Control (2 stars)

Guest

Wow, those Common ratins are so far off it's ridiculous.

N3R0 of 0nSlaught3r wrote:: Wow, those Common ratins are so far off it's ridiculous.

Yeah he should have had Can I Borrow A Dollar at 4.5, One Day It Will All Make Sense at 4, Be at 4, and Finding Forever at 3, and Like Water For Chocolate at 4.5

Guest

No. Not really.

N3R0 of 0nSlaught3r wrote:: No. Not really.

How do you rate them?

Also, the only Common albums that matter:

Resurrection
Can I Borrow A Dollar?
Like Water For Chocolate

Guest

N3R0 of 0nSlaught3r wrote:: Wow, those Common ratins are so far off it's ridiculous.

Whatever Jeff, I just call them like I see them.

Guest

AFutureWithoutAPast wrote:: Also, the only Common albums that matter:

Resurrection
Can I Borrow A Dollar?
Like Water For Chocolate

You didn't like One Day?

E-4000, Ya Smell Me? Posts : 4876 Join date : 2009-05-31

Resurrection - 5
Water For Chocolate - 5ish (Answers is unforgivabley bad)
Borrow a Dollar -4.5
One Day - 4
Be - 3
EC - 2.5
FF - 2
UMC - 2

Kid Joe wrote:: Resurrection - 5
Water For Chocolate - 5ish (Answers is unforgivabley bad)
Borrow a Dollar -4.5
One Day - 4
Be - 3
EC - 2.5
FF - 2
UMC - 2

Are you talking about "The Questions"...the one with Mos Def?

Those ratings looks about right to me.

If I remember correctly, I gave EC a 3 or 3.5 and Be a 4.5, but neither is living up to those ratings in hindsight.

E-4000, Ya Smell Me? Posts : 4876 Join date : 2009-05-31

Yup, Questions is the name of it.

Guest

BE- 4.75
Like Water For Chocolate- 4.5
Resurrection-4.5
Finding Forever- 4.25
One Day- 4.25
Electric Circus- 3.75
UMC- 3.5
Borrow A Dollar- 3.25 (never was feeling this album)

Kid Joe wrote:: Resurrection - 5
Water For Chocolate - 5ish (Answers is unforgivabley bad)
Borrow a Dollar -4.5
One Day - 4
Be - 3
EC - 2.5
FF - 2
UMC - 2

LMAO!!! "Kid" Joe strikes again huh????

these ratings look like something that a dude that wrote for TV Guide would give...just fuckin horrible man

E-4000, Ya Smell Me? Posts : 4876 Join date : 2009-05-31

I can't believe some of yous like Finding Forever so much. I can see diggin on Be, I liked it a lot for awhile, too.

But FF? Weird.

E-4000, Ya Smell Me? Posts : 4876 Join date : 2009-05-31

I AM a tv guide writer!

Amazing...lol

Where are your horrible opinions on Common's discography?

Guest

D.Powell wrote:

Kid Joe wrote:: Resurrection - 5
Water For Chocolate - 5ish (Answers is unforgivabley bad)
Borrow a Dollar -4.5
One Day - 4
Be - 3
EC - 2.5
FF - 2
UMC - 2

LMAO!!! "Kid" Joe strikes again huh????

these ratings look like something that a dude that wrote for TV Guide would give...just fuckin horrible man

Co-Sign, those ratings are GARBAGE!!

Notice that the people who don't like my ratings AREN'T Common fans

E-4000, Ya Smell Me? Posts : 4876 Join date : 2009-05-31

lol

Co-sign your daddy, KJ.

Guest

Kid Joe wrote:: lol

Co-sign your daddy, KJ.

Powell ain't old enough to be my daddy, I'm only about 4 years younger than him.

But Parker, your ratings for Be and Finding Forever are way off.

E-4000, Ya Smell Me? Posts : 4876 Join date : 2009-05-31

I'm sure there are more albums than just those two that we would disagree on. It's not like I didn't listen to them. Hell, I even paid full for them both.

And, if you look at the scores I give his first 4, you can't really say I'm not a fan. I just don't like his last 4. He used to be my favorite emcee, hands down.

KJ Styles wrote:: But Parker, your ratings for Be and Finding Forever are way off.

Gotta say I'm with Parker on both those albums. Both were just plain boring IMO. Be was better, but neither peak over 3.5 stars IMO. The Common Sense period is the only Common that I bump anymore.

Alan wrote:

KJ Styles wrote:: But Parker, your ratings for Be and Finding Forever are way off.

Gotta say I'm with Parker on both those albums. Both were just plain boring IMO. Be was better, but neither peak over 3.5 stars IMO. The Common Sense period is the only Common that I bump anymore.

Same. Common Sense > Common

Guest

Common Market>Common Sense>Common

» Top 10 Individual Regional Final
» 100 Greatest Artists Final
» 100 Greatest Hip-Hop Artists (Final List)
» Top 10 Groups By Region (Final?)
» Artists vs Themselves